The exploration of Mars has captivated scientists and engineers for decades. Humans to Mars: Fifty Years of Mission Planning, 1950-2000 is a NASA History Division monograph authored by David S. F. Portree and published in February 2001[1]. It surveys over 50 years of United States piloted Mars mission planning, detailing how concepts evolved from the early 1950s through the late 1990s[1].
While over 1,000 studies were conducted during this period, the book focuses on 50 representative studies to illustrate a central theme: Mars mission design was shaped not only by technological advancements but also by politics, budgets, changing scientific knowledge, and broader social contexts[1]. The narrative demonstrates that modern Mars planning should preserve and build upon earlier ideas, as many seemingly modern concepts were explored decades ago[1].
The earliest detailed technical proposals for Mars exploration were characterized by their massive scale. Wernher von Braun presented a "grand scale" Mars plan in his work The Mars Project, which called for an enormous expedition consisting of 10 ships, 70 crew members, and approximately 4,000 tons per ship[1]. This massive fleet would be assembled in Earth orbit via 950 ferry rocket flights and would utilize a minimum energy, conjunction class trajectory with a long stay on Mars to reduce propellant needs[1].
Early NASA studies in 1959 maintained the goal of lowering launch mass but explored advanced engines instead of von Braun's chemical approach. NASA Lewis studied nuclear thermal and electric propulsion for a mission profile that would send seven men to Mars orbit and land two on the surface[1]. Ernst Stuhlinger's electric propulsion concept used nuclear power to run ion thrusters, which required significantly less propellant but produced lower thrust, necessitating long spiral trajectories out of Earth orbit and substantial radiation shielding[1].
The robotic Mariner 4 mission fundamentally changed Mars planning by overturning earlier assumptions about the planet. It revealed a cratered, Moon like surface and an atmosphere far thinner than expected, which weakened the credibility of aerodynamic landing ideas like gliders and diminished hopes of finding Martian life[1]. Consequently, the EMPIRE studies shifted focus toward piloted flyby and orbiter concepts that could test human spaceflight systems and justify the development of heavy lift rockets and nuclear thermal propulsion[1].
Following EMPIRE, the UMPIRE studies pushed for longer conjunction class missions of 900 to 1100 days, emphasizing long Mars stays and potential base building rather than brief visits[1]. Despite the harsher reality of Mars, ambitious planning continued. In 1968, Boeing proposed the "Behemoth", a massive nuclear rocket Mars cruiser measuring about 582 feet long and weighing between 1,000 and 2,000 tons at Earth orbit departure[1]. It featured five Primary Propulsion Modules with NERVA engines and was designed for a six person crew using a Mars Orbit Rendezvous approach[1].
In 1969, the Space Task Group recommended a phased program leading to Mars exploration in the 1980s, though they stressed that timing should depend on budget realities and a balanced program rather than a fixed deadline[1].
The Viking missions provided the first real data on Martian surface conditions and resources, shifting In Situ Resource Utilization (ISRU) from a theoretical concept to a practical planning tool[1]. Viking data revealed that Mars could supply useful materials such as carbon, hydrogen peroxide, water, and atmospheric carbon dioxide[1]. A 1977 to 1978 Jet Propulsion Laboratory study utilized this data to assess the production of methane and oxygen on Mars using the Sabatier process, demonstrating how local propellant production could significantly reduce the mass required to be launched from Earth[1].
The 1980s saw a revival of Mars planning, spurred by the Case for Mars conferences starting in 1981, which brought together engineers and scientists to develop mission ideas like cycler transport and ISRU strategies[1]. The Planetary Society funded a detailed 1984 study by SAIC that proposed a split mission architecture using 18 Space Shuttle launches and heavy aerobraking[1].
NASA supported SEI with its 90 Day Study, which produced five reference approaches. However, the estimated $541 billion cost for the most aggressive approach led to severe political opposition, and Congress eventually eliminated SEI funding, causing the initiative to fade[1].
In the 1990s, the Mars Direct proposal became highly influential by combining ISRU, aerobraking, a split mission design, and a conjunction class profile to create a lower cost architecture[1]. It proposed sending an automated cargo lander first to manufacture return propellant from the Martian atmosphere, followed by the crewed vehicle[1].
NASA adapted these concepts into its Design Reference Mission (DRM) in 1993, which utilized a Mars Ascent Vehicle and an Earth Return Vehicle waiting in Mars orbit[1]. The 1997 DRM further reduced mass by eliminating heavy lift rockets in favor of Shuttle derived launchers and nuclear stages docked in orbit[1].
The 1996 discovery of the ALH 84001 meteorite generated immense public enthusiasm, prompting NASA to integrate robotic and human Mars planning more closely and to focus on lower cost, sustainable exploration strategies[1].
Over fifty years of mission planning demonstrate that modern Mars architectures are built upon a robust foundation of historical studies. Concepts like In Situ Resource Utilization, aerobraking, and split missions have deep roots in early planning efforts. As Portree concludes, future Mars exploration should preserve and build upon these historical insights to ensure a practical and sustainable path to the Red Planet, recognizing that successful mission design requires balancing technological ambition with political and economic realities[1].
Get more accurate answers with Super Pandi, upload files, personalized discovery feed, save searches and contribute to the PandiPedia.
Let's look at alternatives: